The Sokoto Caliphate and Inter-State Diplomacy in Western and Central Sudan in the 19th Century

    Cite this article: Aliyu, S. S. and Sama’ila, A. (2021). “The Sokoto Caliphate and Inter-State Diplomacy in Western and Central Sudan in the 19th Century”. In Sokoto Journal of History Vol. 10. Pp. 43-55.
    THE SOKOTO CALIPHATE AND INTER-STATE DIPLOMACY IN WESTERN AND CENTRAL SUDAN IN THE 19TH CENTURY

    Shuaibu Shehu Aliyu

    Director,
    Arewa House Center for Historical Research and
    Documentation, Kaduna



    &



    Abubakar Sama’ila

    Department of History & International Studies, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto



    Abstract

    The Sokoto Jihad which led to the establishment of the Sokoto Caliphate
    is a product of intellectual quest spinning
    for centuries across states in the Sudan. The founders
    of the caliphate „the triumvirate‟ were themselves, the heirs to
    the long tradition of learning lasting a millennium, have distinguished themselves by the intellectual sagacity
    and wisdom that wielded the entire western
    and central Sudan into a single religious-political block. The caliphate
    distinguished itself by the astonishing
    amount of written documents
    and the literary tradition it occasioned. Through its literary influence, the jihad created the
    largest empire in Africa since the fall of Songhai in 1591. In addition, it also provided the inspiration
    for a series of related holy wars in other parts of the Savanna and Sahel far beyond Nigeria's borders that led to the
    foundation of Islamic states in indifferent
    parts of the region. The availability
    of a
    rich body of jihad literature
    has endowed us with numerous studies on various aspects
    of inter-state relations in the region and particularly between the caliphate and its subordinate emirates. However,
    issues surrounding relations between the
    Caliphate and other states in the Sudan has not been adequately treated. In
    fact, less has been written on the
    caliphate‟s relations with some other states such as Morroco, Agadez, Masina, Liptako and the state of Kurani in spite
    of substantial evidence in the Jihad literature on the exchanges of envoys and dispatches between Sokoto and some of
    these states. The main focus of this paper
    therefore is to reappraise the diplomatic relations between the caliphate and
    some of her neighboring states in the
    region and the lessons that could be drawn from such legacy for the contemporary international system.



    Key Words: Sokoto Jihad, Sokoto Caliphate,
    Diplomacy, Scholarship, Inter-state relation



    Introduction


    The Sokoto
    Caliphate was the upshot of the reform movement that started in Hausaland as
    early as 1776 under the leadership of
    a scholar and reformer known as Shehu Usmanu Danfodiyo. By 1809 the movement had captured power in almost
    all the ancient prosperous Hausa states that flourished for over five centuries.1 Within a short period of
    time, the Jihad succeeded in changing the political landscape of the entire Hausa land and to certain
    proportion, most parts of the West African
    sub-region.2
    The Sokoto Caliphate was the largest state in West Africa since the 16th
    century. It was created by Muslim
    reformers in the Hausa states. The revolutionary movement which was closely associated with the founding of the Sokoto
    Caliphate stimulated a unique intellectual tradition.3 At its peak in the mid. 19th
    century, the caliphate stretched 1,500 kilometers from Dori in modern Burkina Faso to southern Adamawa in
    Cameroon and included Nupe lands, Ilorin in northern Yorubaland, and much of the Benue River valley.4 In
    addition, it also provided the inspiration for a series of related holy wars in other parts of the savanna and
    Sahel far beyond Nigeria's borders that led to the foundation of Islamic states in Senegal,
    Mali, Ivory Coast, Chad, Central
    African Republic, and Sudan.
    Sokoto Caliphate existed for over 100 years – a dynasty that bestrode a very large landscape
    and population in the West African
    sub-region.



    The
    availability of a rich body of Arabic sources5 and the narratives of
    nineteenth-century European travellers
    has endowed us with numerous studies of the relationship between Sokoto
    Caliphate and some of its main
    emirates.6 These studies mainly deal with the emirates within the
    confinement of the contemporary
    northern Nigeria. Issues surrounding relations between the Caliphate and other distant areas/emirates outside northern
    Nigeria have not received adequate attention by scholars.7 Compared to the wealth of studies on
    Sokoto caliphate‘s relations with its immediate emirates, less has been written
    on the former‘s relations with Morocco, Massina,
    Agadez 8 and the distant
    tributaries of the caliphate in the western flank. Furthermore, the
    Caliphate‘s intellectual influence on the development of these areas has not been adequately addressed.9



    Similarly,
    since the most important factor in the spread and development of Islam is
    education, the caliphate leadership
    preoccupied itself with teaching and preaching which had spread to different parts of western
    and central Sudan. For instance
    Shiekh who is the architect
    of the movement

















    2.         
    M.U.Bunza, The Application of
    Islamic Law and the Legacies of Good Governance in the Sokoto Caliphate, Nigeria (1804-1903): Lessons for the
    Contemporary Period, Electronic Journal
    of Islamic and Middle Eastern Law, EJIMEL Vol.I.
    , University of Zurich, 2013, p.84.



    3.         
    H. M. Maishanu, Five Centuries of
    Historical Writing in Hausaland and Borno, 1500-2000
    , Macmillan, Nigeria, 2007, P.1.



    4.         
    R.A. Adeleye, ‗The Sokoto Caliphate in the Nineteenth Century‘, J.F.A.
    Ajayi and Michael Crowder, History of West Africa,
    Vol. II,
    London, Longman, 1974,
    p.59.



    5.         
    One of the most outstanding of these sources is Muhammad Bello, Infaqul Maisur fi TarikhBilad al-Tekrur, Annett John (trans), 1922. It is a pioneer
    historical work that deals with the history of the Sudan. It is also eye opener
    for the colonial and postcolonial
    historians on the history of the region. Muhammad Isa Talatar Mafara, an
    Islamic Scholar, Interviewed at his
    House, Gwiwa Low Coast Area,
    Sokoto, 15/09/2021.



    6.         
    Some of the studies include; D. M. Last, The Sokoto Caliphate, Longman, London, 1967, S. J. Hogben and A. H.
    M Kirk-Greene, The Emirates of Northern Nigeria: A Preliminary Survey of their
    Historical Traditions
    , Oxford University
    Press, London, 1966; Y. B. Usman, Studies
    in the History of the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar pape
    r, Lagos, 1979, and Ibrahim
    Sulaiman, The Islamic State and the
    Challenge of History: Ideals, Policies and Operations of the
    Sokoto Caliphate,
    Mansell,
    London, 1987.



    7.         
    On this see for instance, Rossi, B. Between Sokoto and Agadez:
    Inter-Ethnic Hierarchy in the Nineteenth Century. In From Slavery to Aid: Politics,
    Labour, and Ecology
    in the Nigerien Sahel, 1800–2000
    , African Studies, Cambridge, Cambridge University
    Press, 2015.



    8.         
    Djibo Hamani provides detail analysis on the history and evolution of
    the Sultanate of Agadez. The work makes an important
    contribution to the history of the Ayar of Niger. Djibo, Hamani, L‟Adar precolonial: Contribution l‟etudede l‟histoir des etats Hausa,
    Institut de Recherche en Sciences Humaines,
    Niamey, 1975.



    9.         
    See  for
     instance,  M.T.  Usman,  ―Intellectual  Tradition  in
     the  Sokoto  Emirate,  1903-1960‖,  Unpublished  Ph.D, UDUS, Nigeria, 1998.











     remained
    indefatigable, moving from one place to another. He started from Kebbi and
    Zamfara and
    then to other parts of
    Hausaland before he finally settled at Degel, He spent practically nineteenth
    years travelling, teaching, preaching,
    converting and writing along with his expanding team of
    disciples. During such preaching tour, he was silently but consciously building
    all over his itinerary,
    a body of scholars and students whom he left behind to continue instructing his
    increasing
    number of followers on the
    basic tenets of Islam as well as his idea of reform. Definitely, such tours
    also acquainted him with the nature,
    problems, and aspirations of the society.
    The
    movement was
    therefore intellectually
    based; and interestingly enough, those literatures are still very relevant in
    our
    contemporary societies.10
    For proper administration, rule of law and accountability, the triumvirate
    wrote a number
    of books to guide leaders
    of the state as in most parts
    of the Caliphate, scholars were appointed as state officials, hence were partaking in the running
    of the affairs of the state.11 The literary contributions of the Jihad
    leaders therefore, became accessible in other parts of West
    Africa as some of such literatures influenced the subsequent Jihads that took
    place in West African
    region.12 For instance, before his jihad, Seku Ahmad
    acquainted himself with the works of the
    triumvirates
    and it was his reference to those literatures that finally enabled him to
    convince and
    control his Council of Ulama‟u.13 Similarly, Alhaji
    Umar was also influenced by the writings from

    Sokoto Caliphate which he studied thoroughly prior to his movement,
    among others. The pertinent
    question therefore
    is what impact have these literatures made in the promotion of inter-state diplomacy in west and central sudan?. The
    following section provides background survey on the
    Jihadist encounter with the Hausa rulers which eventually
    translates into the establishment of the
    caliphate.



    The Jihad of 1804 and the Establishment of the Sokoto Caliphate


    The Sokoto Jihad started
    after the disagreement which ensued between
    the Sheikh Usmanu Danfodiyo
    and the authorities in Gobir. Dan Fodio and his entire community emigrated from
    Degel and settled in Gudu on the
    north western border of Gobir. After the establishment of the community in Gudu on 21st February 1804 new
    disciples continued to flock to Shehu. Sarkin Gobir later wrote to Dan Fodio and told him that he was
    declaring war on the community.14 The community met, swore allegiance to Shehu and proclaimed
    him Sarkin Musulmi (Commander of the Believers), a title still held by the Sultan of Sokoto.15 Between
    1804 and 1808 most of the Hausa states fall to the Jihadists and Alkalawa, the capital of Gobir, was also captured.16
    The first battle was between Shehu's
    supporters and a small punitive expedition from Gobir. Yunfa's soldiers were
    defeated and that of Usman's took advantage of this to occupy two northern towns, Matankari, and Kwanni on the



     

















    10 . A. Smith, ‗The contemporary significance
    of the academic ideals of the Sokoto Jihad‘ in Usman, Y. B. ed., Studies in the History of the Sokoto Caliphate, New York, 1979,
    p.244



    11.       J.M. Kaura, ‗Sokoto Caliphate
    literature in the context of the 19th century Jihad in Hausaland: A reflection
    on the contemporary relevance
    and challenges‖ 9th Inaugural lecture, U.D.U.S, 2009.



    12.       In respect to this see for
    instance, C.C. Stewart, Diplomatic Relations in Early Nineteenth Century West
    Africa: Sokoto-Masina-Azaouad
    Correspondence, in Y.B.Usman (ed.), Studies
    in the History of the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar Papers,
    A.B.U., Zaria, p.410.



    13.      
    Ibid.



    14.      
    Murray Last, The Sokoto Caliphate, Longman, London,
    1977, p.41.



    15.       Djibo M. Hamani, Contribution AL‟etude De L‟Histoire De Etat
    Hausa: L‟Adar Precolonial (Republique du Niger),
    Institute De Recherches en Sciences Humaines, Niamey, 1975, p.12.



    16 . Ibid.











     



    border of
    Adar. Sarkin Gobir Yunfa wrote, according to Bello, to the Hausa rulers to ask
    for their help.17 They
    promised him help but none of them came, as they were busy facing their own
    internal opposition. Only the Tuaregs
    accompanied Yunfa on his expedition against Gudu. Yunfa, accompanied
    by his Tuareg allies and some Fulani groups not yet rallied to Shehu, wanted to
    cut off the reformers from the road
    to prevent them from fleeing and to destroy them. But some villagers informed Shehu of Yunfa's position. The
    meeting took place at the Kwatto pond (Tabkin Kwatto) west of Gudu where the soldiers of Sarkin Gobir were defeated.18
    In July 1804 the community left Gudu
    and settled in Magabci in the Sokoto region.19 In March 1805 the
    community moved much further south,
    to Sabon Gari, near Zamfara. In
    April, the Jihadists army led by its Sarkin Yaki (war commander) Ali Jedo captured Kabi and by October 1805, the
    community had moved to Gwandu near
    this new conquest.20



    Shortly after
    his arrival in Gwandu, Shehu faced a major attack by the Gobirawa, assisted by
    the Tuareg Kel Geres and Itesan,
    Sarkin Adar and a group of Kabawa. Two encounters took place in Alkalawa, not far from Gwandu. Shortly
    after Alwassa, Namoda, leader of the Fulani Alibawa, based in Zurmi, inflicted a severe defeat on a coalition of
    Tuareg, Adarawa and Zamfarawa.21 The battle of Zurmi forced Tuareg to make peace with Shehu. All the
    while, throughout the Hausa states and in neighbouring regions,
    Shehu's supporters had become organised and were fighting
    against the local rulers. At
    the beginning of 1807, the caliphate forces led by Umaru Dallaje captured the whole of Katsina, thus completing the
    encirclement of Gobir. Subsequently, Kano was conquered at the end of the second year, and later
    Zaria. Furthermore, on 3rd October 1808, the Jihadists stormed Alkalawa and Sultan Yunfa lost his life.22
    With the fall of Alkalawa, resistance to the Jihadists was broken everywhere. The Gobirawa asked for
    peace which lasted until the death of Usman dan Fodio in 1817.



    The Literary Influence of the
    Caliphate Leaders


    The thorough
    intellectual formation of the Jihad leaders, as seen above, qualified them to
    produce hundreds of works on various
    disciplines and different themes, some in the form of deep intellectual works and others written in response to
    urgent matters in their societies.23 Members of the Fodio‘s family and their descendants alone
    produced about 700 works24 in Arabic only, ranging from a lengthy versification to a voluminous
    book. This is besides their writings in Fulfulde and Hausa. These works covered almost all the
    important branches of Islamic sciences known to the Islamic world till then: exegesis, theology,
    Prophetic tradition, grammar,
    syntax, philology, logic,

















    17.      
    Ibid.



    18.       Murray Last, The Sokoto
    Caliphate
    ,…p.28



    19.       From Magabci, located close
    toSokoto, the decision was taken to take the war to the very heart of the
    Gobir, to Alkalawa the capital. Shehu
    in fact, after Tabkin Kwatto, had alliance of the Twareg of Ayar and Adar. The
    attack on Alkalawa was a failure, so the Tuareg deserted Shehu's
    camp. Now he had
    only the Zamfarawa as allies.



    20.       Ibid.



    21.      
    This is a major victory for the Shiekh. See for instance,
    Muhammad Bello, InfaqulMaisur fi TarikhBilad al-Tekrur,



    Annett John (trans), 1922.



    22.      
    Ibid.



    23.       M.T. Usman, ‗Historiography of the Sokoto
    Caliphate Draft Paper,
    June, 2020, p.2.



    24.       154 works by Shaikh Usman; 112 by Shaikh Abdullahi; 162 by Shaikh Muhammad Bello; 295 by their descendants. Total = 723. cf. John Hunwick
    (1995): Arabic Literature of Africa, Vol.
    2: The writings of Central Sudanic Africa.
    Leiden: E.J. Brill.











     



    semantics,
    numerology, science of rhyme and metre, philosophy, etc. Notwithstanding,
    literature of jihad and criticism of syncretic practices can be singled out as
    their particular contribution to the development
    of Islamic science as well as leadership and governance. 25
    Similarly, the Arabic manuscripts and published works amount to the total of 1594 (including the Shiekh‘s writings).26 On the intellectual basis of the Jihad,
    Abdullahi Smith had long contended that the Jihad that led to the establishment of the Caliphate was essentially;



    …an
    intellectual movement involving the conception of an ideal society and a theory of revolution by which this ideals
    could be approached. All ideals are intellectual
    but the ideals of the Sokoto jihad
    are also academic: not academic in the
    sense of unreal or impracticable, but in the sense of educational having to do with what is taught in schools, in
    academies. Whatever else may have inspired them,
    the mujahidun in Sokoto drew their ideas from scholarly literature, from a tradition
    of learning.27



    The main
    argument of the 19th century movement in the high academic posture
    could be found in numerous books
    produced by the jihadists. Some of these writings are to be found in various
    places in northern Nigeria. The
    importance of this literature on the literary culture of northern Nigeria is summed
    up in the following
    sentences:



    In the literature, there
    is everything, the poetry, the prose, the fiction, the true story,
    the parable, the anecdote, most of what we call the creative
    recreational art as well as matters that pertain to
    faith, state, medicine, the applied sciences and the craft. It drew very well from the Islamic traditions of learning
    and writing, leaving us with a
    society that knows more about literacy and education than many who think of it otherwise.28



    The thorough
    intellectual formation of the Jihad leaders qualified them to produce hundreds
    of works on various disciplines and
    different themes, some in the form of deep intellectual works and others written in response to urgent
    matters in their societies.29 The caliphate literature has played a prominent role in reforming the once
    corrupt Hausa society. They are also heavily dependent on classical sources which are still relevant
    in the contemporary society. The Shehu‘s ideas on the imamate and other socio-political issues are contained in a
    number of works such as the Wathiqat ahl al-Sudan,
    the Kitab al-Farq, and the Bayan Wujub al-Hijra to mention just few.



    Another way
    through which the Jihad literature was used intensively is through the
    documented messages which
    were exchanged between
    the Ulama of that time in series of polemic debates
    on

















    25.    For the literature on Principles of leadership see, H. Bobboyi,
    Principles of Leadership according
    to the founding fathers of Sokoto Caliphate,
    CRID, Leadership series, Abuja, 2011.



    26.       See for more, H.M. Maishanu, Five Centuries
    of Historical Writing in Hausaland
    and Borno, 1500-2000
    , Macmillan, Nigeria,
    2007, P.1.



    27.      
    A. Smith,   ‗The
    contemporary significance of the academic
    ideals of the Sokoto Jihad‘
    in Usman, Y. B. ed.,



    Studies in the History
    of the Sokoto Caliphate
    , New York, 1979245



    28.       S. A. Balogun, ‗Position
    of Gwandu in the Sokoto Caliphate‘, in Y.B. Usman, (ed.) Studies in the History of the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar
    pape
    r, Lagos, 1979,  P. 175



    29.       J.M. Kaura, ‗Sokoto Caliphate
    literature in the context of the 19th century Jihad in Hausaland:
    A reflection on the contemporary relevance and
    challenges‖ 9th Inaugural lecture, U.D.U.S, 2009.











     



    controversial
    issues, whereas others were directed to the general public in time of
    turbulences. An example of the first
    type of these messages relates to those exchanged between the Ulama of the Sokoto Caliphate, on the one hand, and Shaikh Muhammad Al-Amin
    Al-Kanemi of Borno, on the other
    hand. In these messages the latter was questioning the justification and
    rationale of the Sokoto Jihad against
    already established Muslim kingdoms (i.e. of Hausa).30 Contemporary
    scholar cited these literature as an
    evidence on the richness of the intellectual debates these Ulama used to conduct through the ‗pen‘.31



    Similarly, in
    Massina, Ahmad Labbo, one of the students of Sheikh Danfodiyo, appeared to have profoundly influenced by the Sheikh, even as they never met physically. Ahmad‘s
    major work titled,
    al-idtirar ila Allah fi Ikhmad ba‟ad ma Tuqad min al-Bid‟a
    wa Ihya‟ ba‟ad
    ma andarasa min al-sunnah,
    was in both content and style similar to Sheikh Usman‘s Bayan Bid‟I Shaytaniyya.32 Bugaje states that, Ahmad had all along been in correspondence with the leadership of the movement in Sokoto, especially Abdullahi
    Fodio.33 In fact, between 1815 to 1816 this contact becamed intensified as Ahmad Labbo sought
    and received legal as well as moral support from the leadership of the Jama‟a in
    his struggle against the Ulama‟ and
    the ruling class in Masina.34 Sheikh Ahmad having obtained Shehu‘s permission in 1817, started his Jihad. By the following year Seku Ahmadu had overthrown the yoke the Bambara
    state of Seku and their surrogates and went ahead to establish an Islamic state made up of five emirates
    administered centrally by a council of forty, from the capital Hamdullahi.35 It is also on record
    that, the influence of Shiekh Usman was naturally not restricted to Seku
    Ahmadu alone, but in the routine administration of the state. It was reported
    that, Seku Ahmadu had difficulty in
    carrying his council with him until he could quote from the Ihya‟ al-
    sunnah
    of Shehu Usman.36 In fact, as argued by Bugaje,
    Seku Ahmadu was considered so much part of
    Shehu‘s enterprise that when Muhammadu Bello took over the Caliphate following
    the demise of the Sheikh in 1817. Bello however demanded bay‟a from Seku Ahmadu. Seku however
    drew Bello‘s attention to Abdullahi Fodio‘s fatwa in Diya‟ul Hukkam, which justifies the existence of two Imams
    in a territory which is so large as
    it render it ungovernable.37



    Umar al-Futi,
    apparently impressed with what he saw in Masina and Sokoto, decided to stay in Sokoto during the reign of Muhammad Bello
    that endedin 1937. During his seven-year sojourn in sokoto, Umar became involved with scholarly activities as well
    as administration. He was appointed a
    judge in Bello‘s court and even took part in some of the military campaigns. He
    married Bello‘s daughter who gave
    birth to a son Habibu.38
    On return to Futa Toro, Umar began vigorous efforts following the footsteps
    of his mentors in Sokoto. The impact of the Sokoto literature reflected in his

















    30.       M. Bello, Infaqq al-Maisur,
    Al-Shacb Press, pp. 155-198.



    31.       M.T. Usman, ‗Historiography of the Sokoto Caliphate‘



    32.      
    Usman Bugaje, The Past as Future,
    Some preliminary Thought on Sokoto Caliphate
    ,
    Pyla-Mak, Kaduna, 2015 P.72



    33.       Usman Bugaje, The Past as Future…p.73.



    34.       C.C. Stewart, Diplomatic Relations
    in Early Nineteenth Century West Africa:
    Sokoto-Masina-Azaouad Correspondence,
    in Y.B.Usman (ed.), Studies in the
    History of the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar Papers,
    A.B.U., Zaria, p.410.



    35.       Ibid.



    36.      
    Usman Bugaje, The Past as Future, Some preliminary Thought
    on Sokoto Caliphate…P.73



    37.      
    C.C. Stewart, Diplomatic Relations in Early
    Nineteenth Century West Africa…



    38.       Abdullahi Smith,
    A
    Little New Light,
    Gaskiya Corporation, Zaria, P.140.











     



    writings. Some of the works
    which had profound influence on Hajj Umar include Shehu‟s works Hisn al-Afham
    min Juyush al-Awham, Masa‟il al-Muhimma and Siraj al-Ikhwan.
    Others include Sheikh
    Abdullahi‟s Diya al-Hukkam and Muhammad Bello‟s Qadh al-Zinad fi amr hadha
    al-Jihad.
    Some of the ideas of
    these works are to be found in Hajj Umar‘s Tadhakirat
    al-Ghafilin, Tadhakirat al-Mustarshidin
    and his famous Rimah Hizb al-Rahim
    ala Nuhur Hizb al-Rajim.39
    He has also written another important book when he was in Sokoto; Suyuf al-sa‟id.40 When Umar left Sokoto, he left with a number of his personal staff , some disciples and students who played a significant role in his movement . Thus, by 1857, he
    had conquered the Bambara state of Segu and established an Islamic state. Thus, besides
    their intellectual value, these works have shown the literary
    contributions of the
    caliphate scholars on inter-state diplomacy in the region.



    The Aspects of Inter-state
    Diplomacy


    With the
    establishment of the Sokoto caliphate, machineries for diplomatic relations
    were already put in place through
    the Jihadists writings
    spreading across the region and beyond as indicated in the
    first part of this paper. All the states neighboring the Caliphate in the East,
    West and North received substantial
    literary influence from the caliphate scholars justifying the Jihad and calling
    for the others to join the
    movement. This in a way creates possibilities of cooperation with the pure and nominal muslims and this gave the
    caliphate tremendous influence in the affairs of some of these states.41 The caliphate for instance, have exercise
    tremendous influence on the many states in Western and Central Sudan and in fact, secured
    allegiance of their leaders. For instance, the caliphate
    has exercise tremendous influence on the sultanate of Ayar and the rival Tuareg
    groups who controlled both the region
    and the trading routes connecting Agadez region with Bornu and Hausa states.42 Similarly, the
    Caliphate had diplomatic relations with Bornu
    in the eastern flank as well other emirates on the western flank as
    examined below.



    a)      The Sokoto-Bornu Diplomatic Relations


    On the eastern
    flank, the literary aspect of the diplomacy between the caliphate and other
    states featured prominently in the
    central Sudan when at the initial period of the Jihad, Kanem-Borno engaged the Jihadists in series of
    intellectual debate through correspondences on the legality or illegality in waging Jihad in an area that
    had long accepted Islam as state religion. This position served as a turning point for the Kingdom of Borno above any
    other state in the Central Sudan in addition
    to its political and religious credence in the Muslim World at the time. In the
    field of scholarship, Borno had no equal in the pre-nineteenth century central Sudan. Apart from its economic and political dominance, ‗its
    intelligentsia, had developed a powerful tradition of Islamic learning and active participation in
    public affairs long before the coming of Islam in Hausaland‘.43 According to Muhammadu Bello, Borno has
    been known for its high position in the sphere of knowledge and
    memorization of the holy Qur‘an.
    According to him:



     

















    39.       Usman Bugaje, The Past as Future,
    Some preliminary Thought
    on Sokoto Caliphate…P.75.



    40.       Abdullahi Smith,
    A
    Little New Light…
    p.140.



    41.      
    Ibrahim Sulaiman, A Revolution in History: The Jihad of Usman Dan Fodio, Mansell, New York, P.117



    42.       Rossi, Benedetta, The Agadez
    Chronicle and Y-Tarichi: A reinterpretation', History in Africa, vol. 43, 2016, P.8.



    43.       Y. B. Usman, ;the
    Transformation of Political Communities: some notes on a significant dimension
    of the Sokoto Caliphate‘, in Y.B.
    Usman,, (ed.) Studies in the History of
    the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar pape
    r, Lagos, 1979, P.34.











     



    Before this holy war took place no country in our land surpassed (Borno)
    in prosperity… Wadai and Bagarmi were
    formally subject to the Sultans of Borno, as
    also Hausa and the neighboring parts of Bauchi. Later, their power
    declined. Many of their chiefs made
    pilgrimage and they were prosperous and contented in the Muslim faith. They stood fast by the law and custom of Islam. Islam was widespread throughout their land. It is
    known that their chiefs and Wazirs and the rest
    of their people were Muslims... There are no found in our towns, students and writers of the Qur‘an equal to theirs. It
    is stated that they remained steadfast up to
    the time that our jihad began.44



    This statement
    from Sultan Muhammad Bello in favor of Borno was a testimony to its greatness, politically and religiously in the central
    Sudan. Its fame and dominance in the political and economic structure
    of the Sudan confirmed its influence over the most prosperous and strongest Hausa states like Kano, Katsina and Daura.
    The military assistance therefore, Borno offered to these states during
    the 19th century
    Jihad, which became
    the main cause of conflict
    with the Sokoto Sultanate could be understood in
    the light of a stronger state protecting its vassals against invasion; more so that they were paying
    annual tribute to Borno before the outbreak of the jihad.45 The scholarly disposition of the leaders
    of the movement, according to Murray Last, impacted on the nature and character of their reform movement and the new
    state of Sokoto they established.46
    Consequently, the jihad movement thus,
    became distinct from the other similar
    movements in West Africa in the nineteenth century.
    That was why the Sokoto leadership engaged al-Kanemi of Borno Sultanate, in dialogue and intellectual debates instead
    settling the case in battle field. Thus, one
    of the basic factors for the intellectual discourses that took place in the
    19th century between Borno and Sokoto
    Sultanates were the capability and position of each of them to defend whatever action it had taken intellectually and
    authoritatively, not by use of arms.47 It is also worthy of note that the religion
    of Islam was very central
    to the two disputing states especially in the administrative and diplomatic affairs.
    Thus, it was normal for them to have debated on anything which was seen as contravening the basis and tenets of the
    religion on which their states structures were founded.



    b)     Sokoto-Ayar (Agadez
    region) Relations


    On the northern fringe
    of the Caliphate, relations between
    Sokoto and the Sultanate of Ayar had been characterized by intense political
    intervention and deliberate diplomatic tactics by the leaders
    of the Sokoto Caliphate to address the divisive nature of the various
    Tuareg groups of the Ayar region
    throughout the 19th Century.48 Available records have
    shown that from the 1810 when Sultan Muhammadu
    Baqiru of Agadez pay homage to Shehu Danfodiyo at Gwandu up to the time of French occupation of Agadez, there were
    series of interventions from Sokoto caliphate to stabilize the internal crises and succession disputes in the sultanate of Ayar which has also been extended
    to



     

















    44.       M. Bello, Infaqul Maysur



    45.       M.U. Bunza, Intellectual Factor in African Diplomatic History:
    Sokoto and Borno Sultanates, 1786-1817, Sociology International, Volume 2 Issue 3 – 2018, P. 216.



    46.      
    Murray Last, The Sokoto Caliphate…Pp. 52-3.



    47.       M.U. Bunza, Intellectual Factor
    in African Diplomatic History… P. 216.



    48.       A.B. Sokoto, Intellectual Foundation of Sokoto
    Caliphate: Scholarship, Faith,
    Revolution and Building
    of an Empire,
    UsmanuDanfodiyo
    University Press, Sokoto, 2014, P.272











     



    Adar.49
    The role of Muhammad al-Baqri was very critical in the relationship between the
    two states. In fact, Shehu Usman
    Danfodiyo considered him as the pillar of Islam in the region hence the caliphate‘s intervention in the Sultanate was located within what Danfodiyo
    considered to be the area of religious and political influence
    of the Sultan of Ayar.50 Similarly, although Sultan Muhammad
    al-Baqri died early (1810) before the completion of the Sokoto Caliphate, his
    influence on the future relation
    between the two states continued up to the end of the century and even beyond.51 According to
    Johnston, Muhammad Baqir, the Sultan
    of Ayar, received flag of the Jihad from Sheikh and he was considered
    to be the first person to collect flag from the Shiekh Usmanu.52 It was said that Baqir visited Shiekh
    and stayed with the Sheikh for one month, studying and assisting him in the foundation of the caliphate and on his way
    back to his hometown he wrote to all the
    neighboring chiefs around him to support and join the Shehu movement.53
    He died before reaching his home town in Agadez.



    After Muhammad
    Baqir‘s death his brother succeeded
    the throne and extend his loyalty and obedience
    to the Shiekh‘s movement.54 Similarly, Johnston, reported that the Emir of Ayar, Muhammad
    Baqiri had come to Shehu in about 1810 and done homage and his successor, Muhammadu Khamma also come in person to
    see the Sheikh at Sifawa for his bay‟a.55
    During this visit a treaty had been
    negotiated whereby the new Emir had undertaken to keep open the desert trade routes and to transfer to Shehu the
    sovereignty of certain northern towns which the Tuaregs had hitherto controlled.56 In this way the distant
    oasis of Ayar and the intervening region of Adar57 had become part of the Empire.58
    What is clear from the above correspondences between Sheikh Usman Danfodiyo and Sultan Baqir is the
    fact that by the beginning of the 19th century, when the Jihad broke out in Hausaland, Sultanate of
    Agadez had already accepted and pay allegiance to the Jihad of Sheikh
    Usman bn Fodiyo.
    Similarly, Djibo Hamani reports an instance of two letters
    written by the Sultan of Morocco, Mulay Sulayman, one addressed to Sultan Muhammad
    Al-Baqri







    49.      
    DjiboHamani cited some correspondences between the Sokoto Caliphate and
    Sultans of Agadez between 1810 and 1839,
    indicating the strong political and diplomatic connection between the two. See,
    Djibo M. Hammani, Au Carrefour Du Soudan Et De La Berberie: Le
    Sultanat Touareg De L‟Ayar,
    Institute De Recherches en Sciences Humaines, IRSH, Niamey, 1989. Translated
    version: At The Crossroads of Sudan and
    Berberia: The Tuareg Sultanate of the
    Ayar…



    50.       Djibo Hamani, …… in Y. B.
    Usman, (ed.), Studies in the History of
    the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar pape
    r,
    Lagos, 1979



    51.       The Sultan of Ayar was even responsible for the creation of one of the
    new great titles of Sokoto, that of Sarkin Sudan
    (King of Sudan), the first holder of which was Muhammad Bello himself, and
    which is now worn by such dignitaries as the Sarkin Sudan of Kontagora (Nigeria).



    52.       
    Johnston, H.A.S, The Fulani
    Empire of Sokoto
    , London, Oxford University Press, 1967.



    53.       Ibid.



    54.       A.B. Sokoto, Intellectual Foundation of Sokoto Caliphate:
    Scholarship, Faith, Revolution and Building of an Empire,
    UsmanuDanfodiyo University Press, Sokoto, 2014, P.272



    55.       Johnston, H.A.S,
    The Fulani Empire of Sokoto P.91



    56.       In respect to this see also,
    Djibo.M. Hammani, Au Carrefour Du Soudan Et De La Berberie: Le
    SultanatTouareg De L‟Ayar,
    Institute De Recherches en Sciences Humaines,
    Niamey, 1989, P. 24.



    57.       Between 1653 and 1687, Ayar
    under Sultan Mugammad Mubarak successfully resented Kebbi influence and even went ahead to annexed Adar one of the
    tributaries of Kebbi. See M.B. Alkali, ‗A Hausa community in Crisis: Kabi in the 19th century, Unpublished M.A. thesis, History, A.B.U., Zaria,
    November, 1969, P.79.



    58.       Djibo M. Hamani, Contribution AL‟etude De L‟Histoire De Etat
    Hausa: L‟Adar Precolonial (Republique du Niger),
    Institute De Recherches en Sciences Humaines,
    Niamey, 1975, P.











     



    (Sultan of Ayar) and the other to Usman Danfodiyo. These letters were in response
    to correspondence in which the
    Sultan of Ayar informed the Sultan of Morocco of the activities of Shehu Usman.59



    c)      Sokoto in the
    western frontier: the Emirates
    of Dosso-Junju-Sayi-Liptako
    axis


    In the western part of the caliphate, Gwandu,
    as indicated in the last section, had been the administrative
    headquarters since 1805 for running the affairs of the reform movement. Shehu migrated
    to Gwandu in the late 1805 with a view to solving the problem of military
    strategy and scarcity of food,
    pasture and water.60 While
    the eastern flank under Muhammadu Bello, had the borders of the caliphate extended running over all Hausa states
    of Kano, Katsina, Daura, Gobir, Zamfara,
    Zazzau, incorporating areas of Bauchi, Gombe Adamawa and some parts of Borno61,
    the Caliphate also wields greater
    influence on the political and religious affairs of Ayar sultanate in the north-eastern part of the caliphate.62 Therefore, after the establishment of
    Sokoto and Gwandu as centers of the
    caliphate in 1809, the western side of the caliphate under Abdullahi extended
    to as far as Yorubaland with emirate
    center at Ilorin. Other areas under the jurisdiction of Abdullahi include Nupe land and further North to Gurma
    countries, Zabarma, Liptako (in present Burkina Faso) and Masina in Mali.63 After the Jihad destabilized the Kingdom
    of Kabi, the caliphate went further west to
    incorporate the areas of the Zabermawa of Dosso as well as the emirates of Sayi
    and Junju. Another area which the
    caliphate extend its influence is the Zarmatarey or Zarma country, which is the area of expansion of the Zarma from
    the Zarmaganda,64 which was at the same time the place of origin of the Zarma. The country is a vast tertiary plateau
    sloping slightly to the south and intersected from north to south with
    fossil tributaries of the Niger river along the Dallols Mawri, Fogha and Bosso. The climate of the area
    is Sahelian, but in the southern tip it has a North Sudanese character.65



    It is worth
    noting that at the beginning of the 19th century, the insidious infiltration of
    the Tuareg broke the fragile balance
    of the Zarmatarey subgroups.66 The Jihad of Usman Dan Fodio led to
    the conquest of Zarma and it led to
    their subsequent submission to the Jihadist. The eastern part of Zarmatarey was ruled by the Tamkalla
    Fulani and the Tuareg, while the western part was spiritually subjugated by the persistent piety and diplomacy
    of Alfa Mamman Jobbo and his descendants.67 In

















    59.       Djibo Hamani reports that
    Sultan of Morocco Mulay Sulayman (1792-1822) wrote two letters, one addressed
    to Sultan Muhammad Al-Baqri and the
    other to Usman Dan Fodio. The letters are dated from July 1810. These two letters
    were published in Infaq-al-Maisur, (CAyaro edition pp. 202-203).



    60.       M.U. Bunza, Gwandu Emirate: The Domain of Abdullahi
    Fodiyo since 1805
    , Gwandu Emirate Development Association, 2018, P.
    164



    61.   Ibid…P.176.



    62.      
    Djibo M. Hammani, Au Carrefour Du
    Soudan Et De La Berberie: Le Sultanat Touareg De L‟Ayar,
    Institute De Recherches en Sciences Humaines, IRSH,
    Niamey, 1989; Translated Version: At The
    Crossroads of Sudan and Berberia: The Tuareg Sultanate of the Ayar.



    63.      
    Ibid.



    64.      
    Zermaganda means the land of Zerma.



    65.       Boube Gado, LE ZARMATAREY: Contriution al‟histoiredes
    populations d‟entre Niger et Dallol Mawri
    , IRSH, Niamey, 1980, P. 11.



    66.       Moumouni Yacouba,
    Contribution a l‘etude du Passe Songhai: L‘histoire du Dendi, PhD Thesis, Department of History,
    University of Code Voire,
    1997, P.20.



    67.       Boube Gado, LE ZARMATAREY P.14











     



    1817,
    Abdullahi Fodiyo led an expedition to Dosso, the capital of the Zaberma
    Kingdom.68 It was consequent upon his success that he
    appointed sarkin Zabarma Zarmakoi as the Emir of Zabarma in Dosso. 69 In the 1820s Dosso
    people mounted some resistance to the Jihadist but finally they were subjected under the administration of the
    Sokoto Caliphate. However, resistance continued down to 1830s and 1840s especially when Issa Korombé,
    sought Kebbi alliance
    against the Caliphate. Korombe joined forces with Dauda Bagaran and Hamma Fandu in
    Kabi, around 1849, coinciding with
    the time of the revolt of Yakuba Nabame, who proclaimed himself Sarkin Kabi and
    set up his capital at Argungu.70
    With the support of Kabi and Tsibiri the Zarma was able to victoriously repelled a Fulani attack at Gorubankassam
    north-east of Dosso.71 In spite of the series of Zarma resistance, Dosso remained under the
    Caliphate as part of the Jurisdiction of Gwandu up to 1856.72 During the time of Emir Ibrahim Halilu bn
    Abdullahi, the Zabarma also rebelled against Gwandu, the rebels however where defeated at Dubadama with the combined
    forces of Sokoto sent by Sarkin Musulmi
    Aliyu Babba, led by his brother Yusuf as well as Umar Nagwamatse to assist the
    Emir of Gwandu73



    Further west of Dosso Emirate are also the Emirates of Sayi, Junju and Liptako.
    The emirates of Sayi
    and Junju (in the present day Niger Republic) came under the influence of the
    western axis of the sokoto caliphate
    with Headquarters in Gwandu. In fact sultan Muhammadu Bello reinforced the forces of the Emir of Gwandu with Sullubawa armies under the leadership and command of Baraden
    Wamakko.74 Sayi emirate was the seat of learned muslim scholar known
    as Modibbo who supplied Gwandu with
    the needed forces and resources with which it run the islamization of the westernmost regions of its territories.75
    Some sources reported that Modibbo or rather Diobbo, and his companion Boubakar Lokouji/Luluje, are two famous clerics
    who established their hegemony in Sayi
    at about 1810.76   Because of
    his reputation as learned and peaceful man, Diobbo soon gained an ascendency over the Fulani in the Sayi
    region who recognized him as their overlord. Sayi therefore, became not only a seat of learning, but also an
    important economic center through which east-west
    trade, especially trade along the river was channeled. By the time Diobbo died
    in 1840, he was by far the single
    most important chief of the west and could claim allegiance from a host of lesser chiefs of the right bank of the river valley.77 Diobbo in turn considered himself
    to be a vassal



     




    68.      
    R.A. Adeleye, Power and Diplomacy in Northern Nigeria,
    1804-1906: the Sokoto Caliphate and its Enemies,



    Longman, London,
    1977, p. 65.



    69.       His name is given
    as Zarmakoi Abul-Hassan as Emir of Zabarma, M.U. Bunza, Gwandu
    Emirate…p.211.



    70.      
    Boube Gado, LE ZARMATAREY…P.15.



    71.       Ibid.



    72.      
    Hogben and Kirk-Green, (1966) and Arnett, The History
    of Sokoto
    , 1922.



    73.       M.U. Bunza, ‗Change of the
    Guards: Vegaries in Dosso-Zarma Relations with Kebbi kingdom and Gwandu Emirate,
    1820s-1880s‘ in B.A. Gado& A. Bako (eds.), Relations
    between Dosso, Kebbi and Sokoto:
    Spaces, Societies, States,
    Cultures, Economy & Politics.
    Abdulmumin University Niamey, (Niger Republic), Usmanu Danfodiyo
    Univeristy, Sokoto (Nigeria) & Kebbi State University,
    Aliero (Nigeria), Decmber,
    2016, P. 151



    74.      
    Ibid.



    75.       For instance, some of the forces
    which Gwandu used for expedition against Gurma were from Say. See, M.U. Bunza, Change
    of Guards….



    76.       Ibid.



    77.      
    Finn Fuglestad, A History of Niger…P.37.











     



    of the Sarkin Musulmi
    in Sokoto.78 In the same manner, Boubakar
    Lokouji/Luluje, Diobbo companion, and the leader of the Fulani who settled down in the middle dallol Bosso also established close ties with Sokoto caliphate, especially with the Emir of Gwandu. By this arrangement, the Zerma, the Mauri, the
    Dendi and also the Kebbawa, were caught in the middle and by about 1830-1835, the first
    three were reduced to a state of vassaldom compelled to pay tributes.79



    In Junju
    Emirate, it was the Alfa Adde who served as representative of Mallam Abdullahi
    bn Fodio and consequently assumed the
    role of an Emir.80 Just like other emirates in the western part of
    the caliphate, Emirate of Junju
    participated and gave assistance to Gwandu in their campaign in the expansion and protection of the caliphate.
    Other emirates that were given flags and played similar role in the western flank include, Emirates of Ngaure, Liptako,
    Lamurdi Torodi, Bitimkogi,Yaga as well as the emirate
    of Macina.81 The latter was said to be particularly under the control
    of Abdullahi bn Fodiyo.82
    It was reported that Ahmad Lobbo continuously paid his annual tribute until the death of ShehuUsman in 1817. According
    to Adeleye ‗it was after some convincing arguments by Ahmad Lobbo, that he was granted some operational autonomy in
    his emirate‘.83 It was upon this
    effective control of the emirates that in terms of appointment in the
    areas under his jurisdiction, he had
    to consult Sokoto or Gwandu for approval.84 This, according to
    Adeleye, was a guarantee of loyalty
    to his overlord and of equitable rule in his province. The west of the caliphate at the time included the Niger valley down
    to Nupe and extended as far west as
    Dendi. Later Gwandu often with sokoto
    help, pushed farther in these directions to include Ilorin in the south and
    Liptako in the West.



    d)     Sokoto-Masina Relation


    The
    Sokoto-Masina relation in the nineteen century has been marked by serious
    diplomatic and religious significance
    in the western sudan. Masina Jihad has exerted great influence of the literary culture of the Sokoto caliphate and thus,
    applied same ideals in establishing Islamic state there.85 Masina derived great deal of inspiration
    from the ideals of the Sokoto Jihad leaders: their literatures, the jihad itself and their ability to
    establish an organised Islamic state of Sokoto. It is from this connection that we can understand how,
    from 1818 through the early years of 1850s, the states of Sokoto and Masina were able to dominate
    politics and economies of central and western sudan vis- à-vis the diplomatic ties among the two states. Masina formally pledges allegiance to Sokoto as early as the starts of the Danfodiyo
    movement. The implication of bay‟a (the swearing
    of allegiance), as per as the
    19th century diplomacy in the central and western sudan, is very
    critical not only in Sokoto-Hamdullahi relations, but throughout the region. Bay‟a and
    its implication, according
    to Stewart, is subject of great complicity that deserves careful attention by historians of

















    78.       Ibid.



    79.       Ibid.



    80.      
    M.U. Bunza, Change
    of Guards….



    81.       Ibid.



    82.      
    R.A. Adeleye, Power and Diplomacy in Northern Nigeria…P.66.



    83.      
    Ibid.



    84.      
    Ibid.



    85.       When the jihad began in Masina, it was an independent movement led by a local Qādirī Fulani, Ahmadu ibn Hammadi. Ahmadu was certainly cognizant of Usman‘s jihad, and the circumstances in which his
    own movement was born were
    very similar to those
    that had occasioned the jihad in Hausaland.









     



    West African
    diplomacy.86 The most critical period of relations
    between Sokoto and Masina therefore, is the 1817-1821
    years immediately following
    Sheikh Usman‘s death. The period witnessed
    the Sheikh Ahmad‘s allegiance and breaking of allegiance (bay‟a) to Sokoto Caliphate. According to Brown‘s account
    of the Sokoto-Masina relations, it appears that the initial
    period of the Jihad witnessed exchanges of envoys
    who were firstly dispatched to Sifawa for the flags, while Shiakh Usman b. Fodio still lived. The
    envoys were retained in Sokoto by the death of the Shaikh and returned back to Masina in 1817-18.87
    Barth also reported that Flags were sent from Sokoto to Shaikh Ahmad. There is also evidence among the Sokoto
    correspondence about the subordinate position
    of Hamdullahi. What is clear from the above narrative is that, Shaikh Ahmad did
    offer bay‟a to Sokoto
    before the death of Shaikh
    Uthman, but it said that it was broken shortly
    afterwards. Abdullahi bn
    Fodio was later reported that he agreed that the break of the Masina Bay‟a are debatable.



    In spite of
    the debacle of broken bay‟a, the
    relation between the two states had been established in the years after 1821. This can be seen in the aftermath of a
    revolt in Masina in 1821 and in an account of correspondence between
    Bello and Shaikh
    Ahmad in 1826. The revolt was led by Galajio (Hammada Badejo) who had joined
    Sheik Ahmad Movement shortly after his Jihad began. In 1819 he travelled to Timbuktu where he studied under Sidi
    Muhammad and it was to him he returned in 1825 in quest of support and encouragement against
    Shaikh Ahmad authority. Subsequently, he and his followers were forced to flee to the
    east where they were received by Gwandu
    and settled in what letter became known as Kurani Emirate. Subsequent mediation
    through the office of Sidi Muhammad
    involved the recording of Sokoto‘s frontiers along the Belehede River which
    marked the frontier between Masina and Sokoto.



    Conclusion


    Contrary to
    the writings of Western scholars who consider the history of Sub-Saharan Africa
    in the pre-colonial period as records
    of dark accounts, conflicts and wars, the discussion contained in this paper demonstrates quite significant
    achievements in African literary and diplomatic story. The emergence and evolution of diplomacy and
    foreign policy of the sokoto caliphate vis-à-vis its relations with other states in western and central sudan reveals
    excellent, constructive, bilateral and beneficial
    inter-state relations within the sub-region.
    Our discussion attempted to show that the Sokoto scholars have used intellectual approach in dealing with
    certain complexities of relating with other
    states that happens to fall outside the direct control of the caliphate: Ayar
    and Massina as example. Even after
    the division of the Caliphate into two: Eastern and Western parts, there were signs through the various correspondences
    to show that states of Massina, Ayar and other smaller emirates that were far away from the Caliphate sought religious
    advice and permission (a sign of allegiance) from the Sokoto Jihad leaders before carrying out certain critical decisions.




    86.       C.C. Stewart, Diplomatic Relations
    in Early Nineteenth Century West Africa:
    Sokoto-Masina-Azaouad Correspondence,
    in Y.B.Usman (ed.), Studies in the
    History of the Sokoto Caliphate: The Sokoto Seminar Papers,
    A.B.U., Zaria, P.410.



    87.   Ibid. p.413.


    No comments:

    Post a Comment

    ENGLISH: You are warmly invited to share your comments or ask questions regarding this post or related topics of interest. Your feedback serves as evidence of your appreciation for our hard work and ongoing efforts to sustain this extensive and informative blog. We value your input and engagement.

    HAUSA: Kuna iya rubuto mana tsokaci ko tambayoyi a ƙasa. Tsokacinku game da abubuwan da muke ɗorawa shi zai tabbatar mana cewa mutane suna amfana da wannan ƙoƙari da muke yi na tattaro muku ɗimbin ilimummuka a wannan kafar intanet.